Inquiring about potential audio surveillance: Does my smartphone or smart home system secretly eavesdrop on all conversations?
Hey there! Welcome to Ask Jerry, the place where we chat about everything tech-related. I'm Jerry, and with a career in engineering and R&D, I've been diving deep into the world of Android and Google for the past 15 years. I'm here to help you tackle any Android-related questions you might have.
If you have tech questions weighing on your mind, whether it's your smartphone or any other device, I'd love to chat about it. Drop me an email at [email protected], and let's get things sorted! Remember, you can remain anonymous if you like, and we promise not to share anything beyond what we discuss here.
Curious about always listening? Sometimes, it seems like smart devices and assistants are lurking around, listening for their wake word. Let's uncover the truth behind this common question:
It's a two-part answer to your question:
- Yes, Always Listening means just that – smart devices and assistants are always listening to grab their trigger word or phrase. This way, they can take action when they hear it and be helpful
- However, they don't always recognize everything or take action. They analyze every sound picked up until they hear their trigger command phrase, at which point they start processing what comes next. If they don't recognize the command phrase or can't fulfill a request, they'll respond with a generic error message.
A Nest Mini works in a similar way. As soon as you plug it in and set it up, it starts listening for its command phrase. Any sounds it picks up are analyzed by low-power software and hardware. It only tries to interpret the sounds as commands if it hears its command phrase.
What about privacy concerns?
Tech companies are transparent about their voice-activated devices' capabilities and privacy policies. There are certainly privacy concerns since these devices are always listening. Some companies might record and send back commands to be checked, and they keep track of everything they think is a valid request for a certain amount of time.
However, some companies claim they don't sell user data. If they hear something that’s not a valid request, they won't keep track of it. You can choose to trust these companies or opt-out of their services if privacy concerns persist.
Personally, I only fully trust something I've built myself. I do use Google Assistant, Gemini, and Google Home, but I take precautions with my usage, such as not installing them in my bedroom or keeping them away from sensitive conversations. Ultimately, you should decide whether you trust these devices based on the information provided by the companies.
In our tech discussions, let's delve into the use of smart-home devices like the Nest Mini, which, similar to other smart devices and assistants, operates on an 'Always Listening' basis, constantly analyzing sounds for its command phrase. This raises questions about privacy, as tech companies, such as those behind Google Assistant and Google Home, are transparent about their privacy policies but may retain user data for a certain period. Nonetheless, you can mitigate concerns by taking precautions, such as not installing these gadgets in sensitive areas or limiting their usage based on your trust in the technology.
